Dateline: New Jersey 2/02/09 11:16 AM
How Government Prolonged the
Depression
Policies that decreased competition in
product and labor markets were especially destructive.
The New Deal is widely perceived to have ended the
Great Depression, and this has led many to support a "new" New Deal to address the current crisis. But the
facts do not support the perception that FDR's policies shortened the Depression, or that similar policies
will pull our nation out of its current economic downturn.
The goal of the New Deal was to get Americans back to
work. But the New Deal didn't restore employment. In fact, there was even less work on average
during the New Deal than before FDR took office. Total hours worked per adult, including
government employees, were 18% below their 1929 level between 1930-32, but were 23% lower on
average during the New Deal (1933-39). Private hours worked were even lower after FDR took
office, averaging 27% below their 1929 level, compared to 18% lower between in
1930-32.
Even comparing hours worked at the end of 1930s to
those at the beginning of FDR's presidency doesn't paint a picture of recovery. Total hours worked per adult
in 1939 remained about 21% below their 1929 level, compared to a decline of 27% in 1933. And it wasn't just
work that remained scarce during the New Deal. Per capita consumption did not recover at all, remaining 25%
below its trend level throughout the New Deal, and per-capita nonresidential investment averaged about 60%
below trend. The Great Depression clearly continued long after FDR took office.
Why wasn't the Depression followed by a vigorous
recovery, like every other cycle? It should have been. The economic fundamentals that drive all expansions
were very favorable during the New Deal. Productivity grew very rapidly after 1933, the price level was
stable, real interest rates were low, and liquidity was plentiful. We have calculated on the basis of just
productivity growth that employment and investment should have been back to normal levels by 1936. Similarly,
Nobel Laureate Robert Lucas and Leonard Rapping calculated on the basis of just expansionary Federal Reserve
policy that the economy should have been back to normal by 1935.
So what stopped a blockbuster recovery
from ever starting? The New Deal. Some New Deal policies certainly benefited the economy by
establishing a basic social safety net through Social Security and unemployment benefits, and by
stabilizing the financial system through deposit insurance and the Securities Exchange Commission.
But others violated the most basic economic principles by suppressing competition, and setting prices
and wages in many sectors well above their normal levels. All told, these antimarket policies choked
off powerful recovery forces that would have plausibly returned the economy back to trend by the
mid-1930s.
The most damaging policies were those at the heart
of the recovery plan, including The National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA), which tossed aside the nation's
antitrust acts and permitted industries to collusively raise prices provided that they shared their newfound
monopoly rents with workers by substantially raising wages well above underlying productivity growth. The
NIRA covered over 500 industries, ranging from autos and steel, to ladies hosiery and poultry production.
Each industry created a code of "fair competition" which spelled out what producers could and could not do,
and which were designed to eliminate "excessive competition" that FDR believed to be the source of the
Depression.
These codes distorted the economy by artificially
raising wages and prices, restricting output, and reducing productive capacity by placing quotas on industry
investment in new plants and equipment. Following government approval of each industry code, industry prices
and wages increased substantially, while prices and wages in sectors that weren't covered by the NIRA, such
as agriculture, did not. We have calculated that manufacturing wages were as much as 25% above the level that
would have prevailed without the New Deal. And while the artificially high wages created by the NIRA
benefited the few that were fortunate to have a job in those industries, they significantly depressed
production and employment, as the growth in wage costs far exceeded productivity
growth.
These policies continued even after the NIRA was
declared unconstitutional in 1935. There was no antitrust activity after the NIRA, despite overwhelming FTC
evidence of price-fixing and production limits in many industries, and the National Labor Relations Act of
1935 gave unions substantial collective-bargaining power. While not permitted under federal law, the sit-down
strike, in which workers were occupied factories and shut down production, was tolerated by governors in a
number of states and was used with great success against major employers, including General Motors in
1937.
The downturn of 1937-38 was preceded by large wage
hikes that pushed wages well above their NIRA levels, following the Supreme Court's 1937 decision that upheld
the constitutionality of the National Labor Relations Act. These wage hikes led to further job loss,
particularly in manufacturing. The "recession in a depression" thus was not the result of a reversal of New
Deal policies, as argued by some, but rather a deepening of New Deal polices that raised wages even further
above their competitive levels, and which further prevented the normal forces of supply and demand from
restoring full employment. Our research indicates that New Deal labor and industrial policies prolonged the
Depression by seven years.
By the late 1930s, New Deal policies did begin to
reverse, which coincided with the beginning of the recovery. In a 1938 speech, FDR acknowledged that the
American economy had become a "concealed cartel system like Europe," which led the Justice Department to
reinitiate antitrust prosecution. And union bargaining power was significantly reduced, first by the Supreme
Court's ruling that the sit-down strike was illegal, and further reduced during World War II by the National
War Labor Board (NWLB), in which large union wage settlements were limited by the NWLB to cost-of-living
increases. The wartime economic boom reflected not only the enormous resource drain of military spending, but
also the erosion of New Deal labor and industrial policies.
By 1947, through a combination of NWLB
wage restrictions and rapid productivity growth, we have calculated that the large gap between
manufacturing wages and productivity that emerged during the New Deal had nearly been eliminated. And
since that time, wages have never approached the severely distorted levels that prevailed under the
New Deal, nor has the country suffered from such abysmally low employment.
The main lesson we have learned from the New Deal
is that wholesale government intervention can -- and does -- deliver the most unintended of consequences.
This was true in the 1930s, when artificially high wages and prices kept us depressed for more than a decade,
it was true in the 1970s when price controls were used to combat inflation but just produced shortages. It is
true today, when poorly designed regulation produced a banking system that took on too much
risk.
President Barack Obama and Congress have a great
opportunity to produce reforms that do return Americans to work, and that provide a foundation for sustained
long-run economic growth and the opportunity for all Americans to succeed. These reforms should include very
specific plans that update banking regulations and address a manufacturing sector in which several large
industries -- including autos and steel -- are no longer internationally competitive. Tax reform that
broadens rather than narrows the tax base and that increases incentives to work, save and invest is also
needed. We must also confront an educational system that fails many of its constituents. A large fiscal
stimulus plan that doesn't directly address the specific impediments that our economy faces is unlikely to
achieve either the country's short-term or long-term goals.
Mr. Cole is professor of economics at the University of Pennsylvania.
Mr. Ohanian is professor of economics and director of the Ettinger Family Program in Macroeconomic Research
at UCLA.
Victor David Hanson
************************************************************************************
Dateline: New Jersey
2/04/09 3:00 PM
The Obama Implosion
The Obama media meltdown ....
Some of us have been
warning that it was not healthy for the U.S. media to have deified rather than questioned Obama, especially given that they tore
apart Bush, ridiculed Palin, and caricatured Hillary. And now we can see the results of their two years of
advocacy rather than scrutiny.
We are quite literally after two weeks teetering on an Obama implosion—and with no
Dick Morris to bail him out—brought on by messianic delusions of grandeur, hubris, and a strange naivete that
soaring rhetoric and a multiracial profile can add requisite cover to good old-fashioned Chicago
politicking.
First, there were the sermons on ethics, belied by the appointments of tax dodgers,
crass lobbyists, and wheeler-dealers like Richardson
—with the relish of the Blago tapes still to come. (And why does Richardson/Daschle
go, but not Geithner?).
Second, was the
"stimulus" (the euphemism for "borrow/print money") that was simply a way to go into debt for a generation to
shower Democratic constituencies with cash.
Then third, there
were the inflated lectures on historic foreign policy to be made by the clumsy political novice who trashed
his own country and his predecessor in the most ungracious manner overseas to a censored Saudi-run press
organ (e.g., Bush is dictatorial, the Saudi king is courageous; Obama can mend bridges that America broke to
aggrieved Muslims—apparently Tehran hostages, Rushdie, serial attacks in the 1990s, 9/11, Madrid, London
never apparently occurred; and neither did feeding Somalis, saving Kuwait, protesting Chechnya,
Bosnia/Kosovo, billions to Egypt, Jordan, the Palestinians, help in two Afghan wars, and on and
on).
Fourth, there was the campaign rhetoric of Bush shredding the Constitution—FISA,
Guantánamo, the Patriot Act, Iraq, renditions, etc.—followed by "all that for now stays the same" inasmuch as we
haven't ben hit in over seven years and can't risk another attack.
Fifth, Gibbs as
press secretary is a Scott McClellan nightmare that won't go away, given his long McClellan-like relationship
with Obama (McClellan should have been fired on day hour one on the job). Blaming Fox News
for Obama's calamities is McClellan to the core and doesn't work. He already reminds me of Reverend Wright's
undoing at the National Press Club—and he will get worse.
Six, Biden is being
Biden. Already, he's ridiculed the chief justice, trashed the former VP, bragged on
himself ad
nauseam in Bidenesque weird ways, and it's only
been two weeks.
And the result of
all this?
At home, Obama is becoming
laughable and laying the groundwork for the greatest
conservative populist reaction since the Reagan Revolution.
Abroad, some really
creepy people are lining up to test Obama's world view of "Bush did it/but I am the world": The North Koreans
are readying their missiles; the Iranians are calling us passive, bragging on nukes and satellites; Russia is
declaring missile defense is over... Can you see
why the rest of the world
wanted him in?
This guy was a
nobody outside of South Chicago poiltics until Oprah had him on her couch every week. Then the Democratic press
made him and the idiots of our country elected him.
Now, those who
voted for him are stuck with him but unfortunately, so are the rest of us.
Hoepfully, it will
be proved that he is ineligible to be President since he was born in Mombassa, Kenya and removed from
office.
**************************************************************************************
Dateline: New Jersey 2/05/09
2:44PM
Hmnnn...the Stimulus Plan
Okay, everyone get ready for the great Obama
stimulus plan.
And he thought this up on his own without the
help of Jesse Jackass or Al
Sharptongue.
Now, unless you are a bank or in the movie
industry (which backed The Kenyan to the max), you will be receiving back, your own tax dollars to the tune of
a whopping (drumroll, please) $500...ta da!
So, where do you wisely spend this money to
jump start our economy?
Wal-Mart? No, all the money will go to China .
Gas? Nope, the Arabs will just get
richer.
A computer? They may just as well
give us rupees to spend
Get healthy, fruit and vegetables?
No, that all comes from Mexico, Honduras and Guatemala
Car? No, the Land of the Rising
Sun, Japan will get that, for sure.
And anything that you can buy at a
Dollar Store, that breaks before you get to the parking lot, will just go to Taiwan.
Wait...I got it! A tattoo. That is
as American as you can get.
Yes, a big bold tattoo that
reads:
Obama:
America's Mistake!!! February, 2009
Well, after all. The tattoo will
last longer than the $500 and the tattoo will prove that you were one of the first to call this guy out,
since the press does not have the balls to do it.
****************************************************************
Dateline: New Jersey February 9. 2009
1:38PM
What you will read below is normally
not what we post but then again, I get to post whatever I want and this is important medical information but
MORE IMPORTANTLY it is afriend of mine who sent this to me.
PLEASE FORWARD THIS TO EVERYONE IN
YOUR E-MAIL LIST. It could save your life or someone you love.
My husband Ernie was in several
hospitals 8 months before he passed away. Because I spent 4-5 hours a day in the
hospital each day I became aware of many problems that occur during a long
hospital stay that the patient and family have little or no control over One
of the most serious and deadly is called C-Diff. If you go to the hospital and see a
sign on the wall outside the room of a patient and everyone going into the
room has a gown on.....there's a good chance that person has C-Diff. Even though
you may not have heard of it....it is very
common, very contagious and very
dangerous.
C-Diff is actually caused by the
patient getting too much antibiotics. I understand it is an infection in the
bowels. It causes diarrhea like something you probably have never
seen. It is terrible and depletes your body of everything including every
ounce of energy. Once you are that weak, it effects all parts of your body,
and the patient just gets worse and worse.I was told by the infectious disease
doctor that the only cure was more antibiotics. Unbelievable, but that's what
he said and did.
So often you see people go into a
hospital and the get weaker and weaker, my uneducated guess would be that C-Diff is the
culprit even though the family may not be told that.
NOW THIS IS THE REASON FOR
THE LETTER.........
Yesterday I talked to a woman and she
told me that her father had C-Diff last July at the age of 87. He was very
weak and unable to even sit up. He was treated at Weil Cornell in New York City
and is well and active. Their treatment included antibiotic enemas. If you know
anyone who has it, I'm sure if you call them they will put you in contact with the
correct doctor who would inform your doctor of the complete treatment that he uses.
Obviously not many hospitals are aware of this of this successful
treatment.
This information could save someones
life. I know it would have been a blessing if I was aware of this when Ernie
was suffering with the condition. Again, please pass it on to everyone in your
e-mail list.
Joan Benson
**********************************************************************
|
Dateline: New Jersey February 10, 2009 9:57PM
Ouch, that is what a stimulus feels
like!!!
The Magic Kenyan's non-tax paying
Treasury guy rolled out the stimulus plan today and the market tanked 385 points.
People are surprised. Why
so? Everybody he appoints to a position has a tax problem, so the only thing they know about taxes is how
NOT to pay them.
And the guy running the show
is not even eligible to be the Presidemt.
Oh, that is right he is
the guy who is going to change everything.
Well, he appointed all
Washington Clinton insiders, closed Guantanamo, as his first order but did not attend the ball for our Medal of
Honor recipients and the market is plummetting.
Change? Yeah, it is
getting worse.
The only positive is
that so far he has shut out Jesse Jackass and Al Sharpton. They have taken a back seat to the Big
O.
She may even have her own room at the
White House. Maybe the Lewinsky suite.
She better be careful
because 'ol Arkansas Billy boy may not have turned all his keys in 8 years ago.
*************************************************************
Dateline: New Jersey 2/13/09 1:34
AM
Received this from a dear friend of nearly 45
years who happens to work for a local government. So, I will not divulge her identity but 45 years! She must have
been very young.
T his is an insult and
a kick in the butt to all of us...
Get mad and pass it on
- I don't know how, but maybe some
good
will come of this
travesty.
If the immigrant is
over 65, they can apply for SSI and Medicaid and
get
more than a woman
on Social Security, who worked from 1944 until
2004.
She is only getting
$791 per month because she was born in 1924
and
It is
interesting that the federal government provides a single
refugee
with a monthly
allowance of $1,890. Each can also obtain
an
additional $580 in
social assistance, for a total of $2,470 a
month.
This compares to
a single pensioner, who after contributing
to
the growth and
development of America for 40
to 50 years, can only
receive a monthly
maximum of $1,012 in old age pension
and
Guaranteed
Income Supplement
Maybe our pensioners
should apply as refugees!
Consider sending this
to all your American friends, so we can all
be
ticked off and maybe
get the refugees cut back to $1,012 and
the
pensioners up to
$2,470. Then we can enjoy some of the money we
were
forced to submit to the Government over the last
40 or 50 or 60 years.
Please forward to
every American to expose what our elected
politicians
have been doing over
the past 11 years - to the over-taxed
American.
SEND THIS TO EVERY AMERICAN TAXPAYER YOU
KNOW
*************************************************************************
Dateline: New Jersey 2/13/09 2:07 PM
The Middlle Class
Bandaid
The
stimulouse bill is signed , The Kenyan went on TV and used the word
defining about 88 times in 35 minutes and people are cheering, a temporary
fix.
Well, not everyone bought into it as Wall
Street is stilli running in red numbers.
4.1 millons homes have been foreclosed on
already and another 4.84 million will be foreclosed on between today and the end of
2011.
But bank execs have bonus
pay.
*********************************************************************************************
DATELINE: New Jersey 2/18/09 4:30 PM
|
What did they know and when
did they know it?
For those of us old enough,
just recall, for a moment, the televised Watergate hearings that led to
the resignation of Richard Nixon as
President.
More than likely, this matter
would have been presen ted on TV, some
minor findings released and the President slightly embarassed, but continuing in
office.
Except, for one man, Howard
Baker of Tennessee, who no matter what was offered by the defense, still finished
every presentation, every day (when referring to
Nixon):
"
What did he know and when did he know it?
"
Now, Baker was flat out annoying because that is ALL he ever lent to the
hearings and, more annoying to me, because I thought Nixon was
terrific.
But, it was Baker and Baker alone that kept the heat and he is to
be roundly applauded for his tenacity of effort.
Let's fast forward 25 years later and in May 1999, a man reprorted
to the Boston office of the Securities and Exchange Commission that Madoff
Securities is a fraud.
The matter is " filed ".
On November 7, 2005 he reports directly to the top SEC people that
Bernard Madoff's hedge fund is, in fact, the largest Ponzi scheme in the world and
will cause world banks and markets to tumble.
The matter is " re-fiied ".
If you want to read the report to the SEC, here it
is:
http://www.usviews.org/MadoffAlarm.pdf
********************************************************************
Dateline: New Jersey 21/9/09 $:13PM
And...Mr.
Obama???
CitiGroup stock fell 13.8% today while
Bank of America dropped 14% and the Dow closed at the LOWEST level in 6
years. And we are not done.
I don't seem to hear as many people
talking about how they voted for him.....hmnnnnn.
****************************************
Dateline: New
Jersey 2/20/09 7:00 AM
And whether you agree with him or not, he calls it as he
sees it and that is more courage than most people will ever
show.
Who the
"f" is this piece of flotsam, Holder? Cowards?
What
army, what war, what conflict did this
pant load
participate in? Holder should resign and find
a more
suitable
career,
he is incapable of representing this nation as an
attorney
g eneral. How dare this hack
insult me, my father, my
Uncle.....who all served to preserve his right to be a
moron!
He's
concerned about racial separatism on the weekends
outside
of work?
What does
this puke bag think I want to do......listen to rap
musi c, wear pants off
my ass and drink Colt
45 like his
bretheren?
What is
it about racist blacks who not only have
complete
equality,
jobs, schooling, housing and even the
white house
expect.........me to just unlock my doors so
some
ghetto
trash can hang out in my living room and trash the
place?
This
pig Holder thinks that working with his
ghetto brothers
isnt
enough, but we should "socialize" with
them on our
off time.
This is the worst administration in my life time......
and it's
only been there about a month.
What a
collection of tax
c heats, bigots, racists, neo
marxists
and lying
scumbags.
This
takes some effort to beat the Jimmy
Carter nightmare and
the Bubba
Clinton circus in being the most inept
collection of
hacks,
incompetent bullshit artists making believe they have
clue
about banking, economics, jobs, foreign affairs.
Obama and
his crew of Chicago hoodlums keep babbling some
crap
about making jobs? Where would
that be...in China?
The fool
can't figure out the factories and
industries that could
possibly
hire Americans are gone.
Unless
this fool is going to rebuild consumer product
manufacturing first in this nation, remove the illegals who
are
bleeding
the health and education funds......its just more crap
talk.
What the
"F" jobs is this "activist" going to make.....he
never ran
a business, never managed a business, never created
a
product.......nothing. You must start with base jobs,
which
will hire displaced Americans, who may not be qualified
to be
aero space engineers tomorrow, into consumer level
production to bring
back the basic manufacturing skills.
You have
to slow down the overwhelming Chinese
imports,
starting
with food products, toys, electronics, consumer
products
with incentives to return those productions to the US,
either
b y quality requirements or taxing the
crap from China.
Since
they buy little from us, and need the
heavy industrial
products
they do buy from us, more than we need
their junk
products,
they would hardly mount an effective retaliation.
Illegals must be
deported, they cost us billions in medical and
education
funds, not to mention the 40 billion
they send
"home"
tax free.
But I
won't hold my breath for this messiah to
wake up and
start
working for Americans, maybe I should start that 1950's
bunker
now since he really has a love for the Muslims who
told him
over and over.....they want to kill us.
This
basically is a stupid man regardless of
his time sitting in
Columbia
and Harvard, now in a position way over
his ability
to study
American history, its context in world affairs
that face
the U.S.
This
insipid approach to world affairs is downright
frightening,
yet a
result of over 30 yrs of creating an electorate of
idiots
based on
urban public education that blatantly
created a
generation of pacifists, fools and
dolts who lost the
analytical
ability
to make rational decisions.
Most of
the under 40 white voters who follow
this liberal
cunard
are fools and lemmings.
These
children of hippy parents are genetically challenged to
overcome
their drug infected DNA, and we all must
suffer.
Okay,
did he leave anything unsaid???
|
|